The Church at Laodicea
The Deception of the Charismatic Renewal
(AD 1900-Tribulation)
And unto the angel of the church
of the Laodiceans write; These things saith the Amen, the faithful and true
witness, the beginning of the creation of God; I know thy works, that thou art
neither cold nor hot: I would thou wert cold or hot. So then because thou art
lukewarm, and neither cold nor hot, I will spue thee out of my mouth. Because
thou sayest, I am rich, and increased with goods, and have need of nothing; and
knowest not that thou art wretched, and miserable, and poor, and blind, and
naked: I counsel thee to buy of me gold tried in the fire, that thou mayest be
rich; and white raiment, that thou mayest be clothed, and that the shame of thy
nakedness do not appear; and anoint thine eyes with eyesalve, that thou mayest
see. As many as I love, I rebuke and chasten: be zealous therefore, and repent. (Revelation 3:14-19)
By now it will be obvious to anyone who
has been reading these messages with one eye on the timeline of church history
that with the letter to the church at Laodicea, we have entered the final period
of church history. It will be just as obvious to anyone who has any perception
about what has characterized the church in this century that the predominant
unique characteristics of this period have been brought about by what has been
termed “the Charismatic movement.”
In our discussion of the nature of the final period of
church history, we are not any longer focusing on the state of the mainline
denominations, because they are the subject of the letter to the church at
Sardis. We are not overly concerned with recent events in the Roman Catholic
communion, because that is a continuation of a branch of “the church” that
was covered in the letter to the church at Thyatira, wherein we noted that that
church will continue on into the Great Tribulation.
We are not even overly concerned with recent developments in
“fundamentalism,” as we saw that the rise of the dispensational,
premillennial fundamentalist movement, and the churches that have flowed from
that, were the subject of the letter to the church at Philadelphia. We noted
that that church is given a promise that it will not enter into the Great
Tribulation along with the Catholic church and the denominations, but that it
will be “kept from” the judgments that are to fall during that period of
time.
So we are looking for a 20th century testimony of the
“church” that is not primarily associated with the Catholic church, the
mainline denominational church, or the premillennial fundamentalist church
movement—but which itself embodies a “spirit” and a “testimony” unique
to this century.
So, what aspect of the present day church can be said to
have been introduced subsequent to the rise of fundamentalism in the late 19th
and early 20th centuries? There are many clues within the message itself.
First of all, note the derivation of the name. Lao, as we
noted when discussing the Nicolaitans, is the Greek term for the laity, or the
people, in the sense of the common man. Dicea is the Greek word for “power”
or “authority”, or even “rights.” This then is the church of “people
power,” “people’s rights,” or “civil rights.” It is interesting that
the mindset of our age is an overriding concern with people’s rights—human rights, women’s rights, senior’s rights, patient’s rights,
children’s rights, everyone’s rights but “God’s rights.”
Secondly, let’s look at the attitude this church holds of
itself. It is a church that feels it “has arrived.” The Lord says this
church claims to “have it all.” This is the church of the “prosperity
gospel,”
the “name it and claim it” church, the church that believes that all the
gifts of the Holy Spirit are found within it—they have the “recovery” of
all that has been “missing” in the church for two millennia, they have been
blessed by the “refreshing” of the “latter rain.” The leaders of this
church have no problem filling huge halls, amphitheaters, and stadiums were
self-congratulatory services are held—where the communicants are reassured,
“We are the people!” This is cable–channel Christianity in its most
glorious, most enthusiastic, most extravagant display of “Christ’s power”
to overcome the world, the devil, sickness, and poverty.
And what does the Lord, who is supposedly to be “honored
out of his gourd” by all this pageantry, think about it? It makes Him literally
sick to His stomach. The vernacular would have it, “It makes Him want to
puke.” In fact, the nicety of the King James English almost obscures the fact
that the Lord promises this church that He will vomit them up and spit them out. Taken in context with the promises given to the other
three churches that exist up to the time of the Rapture regarding what will
happen to them at the Lord’s return, there is a picture here of a church that
is almost taken up in the Rapture, but then is spued out back to the earth.
Although there have been any number of books and articles
published in recent days comparing Laodicea to the current condition of the
church. They generally focus on the issue of lukewarmness, and a preoccupation
with material wealth. But it is easy to read these books and believe they
are about those other Christians out there. The fact of the matter is,
this is the age in which we live. In effect, we are all of the Laodicean
era of church history. Therefore, we should take extra care to study this letter
with the aim of discovering just what it is about this particular church that
the Lord finds so unpalatable.
Anyone who has been active in “the church” over the last
several decades is aware that believers outside of the mainline denominations
tend to identify themselves as either “fundamental” or “charismatic,”
and these two camps tend to be at odds with each other over a host of issues.
“Boiled down,” however, the main issues could be summarized thusly:
• Charismatics
tend to believe they have more of everything than their fundamentalist brethren, more “gifts,” more “anointing,” more “power,” including
the power to heal, the power to prophecy, and the power to bring down the
blessings of Deuteronomy 28 upon their finances and business dealings.
• Fundamentalists
tend to interpret scripture literally and therefore they see the promises of
Deuteronomy
28 as pertaining to promises literally specific to Israel, and New Testament
miracles as “signs” given at the beginning of the age to mark the
introduction of a new “dispensation.”
In the same vein, fundamentalists tend to be
premillennial in their eschatology, teaching that it’s going to get worse
before it gets better; that our “hope” is the soon return of the Lord Jesus
in the air to “rapture” true believers from the earth before the judgment of
God falls on an unbelieving world. These is easily contrasted with the
eschatology of the Catholic church and the mainline denominations, as they
believe in neither the rapture, nor the return of the Lord to establish a
kingdom on this earth.
When it comes to charismatic eschatology, however, there is much confusion
about what we are waiting for. For the most part, the movement in general seems to feel God is going to
gain the victory over the world system by empowering “His church” or “His
army” to spread the gospel. Most charismatic congregations are preparing in
one way or another to “go through the Tribulation” and win the victory in
the end. This is the heart of amillennialism, and is the kind of thinking that
influenced the Catholic and Reformation churches to militant action to take over
lands and kingdoms by force if necessary in the name of God.
We have already seen that this issue of amillennial
eschatology versus premillennial eschatology has been an issue addressed in each
of the churches that will exist on the earth at the time of the Lord’s return.
There are those in the church today who feel this is a “divisive” issue and
doesn’t effect how we live our lives as Christians and so should not be
discussed or “worried about.” One of the purposes of this article is to show that this issue is of
the greatest importance to the Lord, and His assessment of any church
necessarily takes into account the attitude of that church toward His promise to
return for His own and keep them from the Tribulation that is coming upon all
the world.
A little meditation on this issue reveals the reason why. A
church’s teaching in this area will have a significant impact on the attitude
of believers toward the world—this world in which we live. It is a
generalization to say—and nevertheless true—that amillennial eschatology
will result in a church that is basically “at home” in the world. It feels
its place is here in the world—it’s mission to change the world and bring in
the Kingdom in a spiritual or allegorical sense that the Lord intends to bring
literally.
“Premillennialism” on the other hand results in a church
where the believers are expecting to be “outta here” in short order. These
believers will be more concerned with storing up treasures in heaven than in
learning how to “cash in” on their “heavenly bank accounts” to meet
current needs here on this earth. Realizing the time is short, they generally
have a greater sense of urgency about “saving souls,” while
“charismatics” are generally more concerned with befriending fundamentalist
believers so that they can lead them into the “fuller gospel” of gifts,
miracles and prosperity. The fundamentalists beat the bushes and “get them
saved,” and then the Charismatics get a hold of them and get them “baptized
in the Holy Spirit” so that their focus changes from the soon return of the
Lord to such distractions as the “fullness of the five-fold ministry,” the
recovery of the gifts, spiritual mapping, etc.
The rather muddled eschatology that teaches that the church
is headed for a time of great persecution, while also teaching that the church
is headed for its most glorious period of awing the world with signs and wonders
and miracles makes for a rather unclear scenario of the end times. And it
is this confusion that causes most believers of the Charismatic persuasion to be “lukewarm”
in regards to His return. If indeed the church is to take the brunt of the
judgments during the Tribulation, that is not much to look forward to. And
if the church is going to rise up in might revival and win cities and nations to
Christ unlike ever before, who wants to see such a glorious time come to an
end? So, although Charismatic teachers use fundamentalist terminology in
speaking of the Last Days and the Second Coming, it is not clear at all what it
is we are really to expect.
Just as in the first letter to the church in Ephesus, many
teach that the “first love” the Ephesians lost was their love for the Lord,
most teachers today teach that the Laodicean church is lukewarm in its love for
Jesus. But just as in the first case, that “first love” may very well
be referring to the love of the saints for each other rather than their love for
Jesus, so in this last latter the lukewarm attitude could very well be a
reference to a “moderate” position between amillennialism (cold) and Premillennialism
(hot). Charismatic eschatology does not deny that the Lord is returning to
the earth (it's not that cold), but on the other hand, they have a lot of things
to do first. Their eyes are on themselves as they anticipate going out
into the world to lead the greatest revival that has ever been. Therefore,
they are not waiting for the Lord to return any day (they are not that
hot). Not cold, and not hot. Not amillennial, and yet not quite
premillennial. A muddled, wishy-washy, lukewarm eschatology, or attitude
toward the Lords' return, is a major characteristic of the Charismatic movement,
which encompasses Third Wave, Third Day, Kingdom Now, Latter Rain, Manifest Sons
of God, and Man Child scenarios—but speaks little of the Lord Himself actually
setting His feet on the ground and sitting on a throne in Jerusalem.
So then because thou art
lukewarm, and neither cold nor hot...
No doubt this will be a hard pill to swallow for many in
this age who are involved in this type of church or even this type of ministry. The primary message is that
those who are most involved are
totally unaware of their true condition, from the Lord’s point of view. Of course, according to the message itself, the predominant
trait of the Laodicean church is self- deception. That is to say, one of the
outstanding characteristics of a true Laodicean church is that it has no idea
that it is a Laodicean church!
But deception, and self-deception, is the hallmark of the
end times. The Lord Jesus talked about it in Matthew 24. Paul expounded on it in
II Thessalonians 2, calling it “strong delusion.” Paul indicates that
those who fall prey to this delusion would be those who “received not the love
of the truth.” Although this passage is generally accepted by
Premillennialists as referring to a deception that takes over the world
following the rapture and the revealing of the Antichrist, when taken with
Jesus’ own warning that the deception that would come in the last time would,
if it were possible, deceive even the very elect, it should be ample warning
that in these closing days of the church age, the winds of deception and
delusion are reaching tempest proportions.
Let us simply note a few other things about this final
letter that indicate further evidence that this message is to the church of the
20th century, not the second century.
First of all, note the Lord’s self introduction to this
church. He asserts and affirms that He is the “beginning of the Creation of
God.” A good message to a church that exists at a time when the world has
decided there is no God and there was no creation.
Another sign that this letter was written with the 20th
Century in mind is the admonition, “I counsel you to buy from me white
raiment, that you may be clothed, that your nakedness not appear.” We live in
an age when Paul’s admonition to women to maintain “modesty” and
“shamefacedness” seems almost comical. Nakedness and near nakedness do not
shock us anymore.
Behold, I stand at the door,
and knock: if any man hear my voice, and open the door, I will come in to him,
and will sup with him, and he with me. To him that overcometh will I grant to
sit with me in my throne, even as I also overcame, and am set down with my
Father in his throne. He that hath an ear, let him hear what the Spirit saith
unto the churches. (Revelation 3:20-22)
Revelation 3:20 is one of the most well-known verses in
scripture. It is also one of the saddest when seen in its context.
In the passage, it is the Lord Jesus standing outside His
own church. The church doesn’t even realize the Lord is not among them—but
rather standing outside, seeking any individual that will hear His voice. This
again underscores the fact that since AD 600, the Lord has placed his message to
the overcomers before the exhortation to hear what the spirit is saying to the
churches. He continues to speak in any age to those individuals who are willing
to follow Him, and not some denomination; Him, and not some creed or statement
of faith; Him, and not some “historical position.” The Lord has not changed
one bit since the day He ascended to sit at the right hand of the Father. The
church has changed, and with the exception of one bright, shining moment, it has
generally been a change for the worse.
I Jesus have sent mine angel to
testify unto you these things in the churches. I am the root and the offspring
of David, and the bright and morning star. And the Spirit and the bride say,
Come. And let him that heareth say, Come. And let him that is athirst come. And
whosoever will, let him take the water of life freely. For I testify unto every
man that heareth the words of the prophecy of this book, If any man shall add
unto these things, God shall add unto him the plagues that are written in this
book: And if any man shall take away from the words of the book of this
prophecy, God shall take away his part out of the book of life, and out of the
holy city, and from the things which are written in this book. (Rev. 22:16--19)
The Lord obviously takes the prophecies contained in this
last book of the New Testament very seriously. The book is called the Revelation,
not because it is intended to be difficult to understand, But because it is intended to
reveal. The problem is we don’t particularly like to see what it is that is
being revealed in the seven letters to the seven churches of Revelation. If
taken seriously, these messages could result in a drastic change in your
Christianity, your attitude toward the brethren, and how you choose to worship
the Lord in spirit and truth. Taken seriously and believed, these letters could
really shake up your life. Certainly, if the church really understood these
letters, they would definitely shake up the church.
Note again that the Lord bears witness to the fact that He
is not only the Root, but the Offspring of David, the King—the King that was
promised would be a descendent of David's to sit on the Throne of Israel, to
order it forever.
He which testifieth these things
saith, Surely I come quickly. Amen. Even so, come, Lord Jesus. The grace of our
Lord Jesus Christ be with you all. Amen.
|